The Business Model Generation
I have a confession. Creating a value proposition for My City Lives has been such an exercise in futility thus far, that I had conceded defeat despite knowing its importance to my startup’s strategy. Oh yes, and I have a MBA. Somewhere, a former professor of mine is shaking his head. I don’t blame him though, because until recently I was equally as troubled by this inexplicable failure on my part.
The turning point, however, was my introduction to Business Model Generation (http://www.businessmodelgeneration.com) - a book for innovators, visionaries and game changers that is unlike anything I’ve seen before. Sure that sounds like hyperbolic-fan-boy-rhetoric, but its worth noting that we have yet to recommend a book in the history of this blog. Whether that’s enough or not, download or view the sample provided on the site to see for yourself.
When doing so, you’ll immediately see the value and uniqueness of the book ’s design, collaborative thought and creativity (another reason why its a good fit to discuss here). You’re also provided an introduction to The Canvass, a sophisticated yet simple structure created by the authors to map out your business model and the determine your resulting strategy. As you can see from the image, The Canvas is simple and visual which is part intended for easy digestion and part recognition of the importance of the space where design and business meet. The overall product is more than just your average book on business model generation – this is an atypical handbook for a generation who are using business models to create change. The lack of anything remotely similar to this helps explain my own issues with developing a Value Proposition – the books and paradigms that I had studied were created before the movement for ‘profit with a purpose’ really gained steam.
I’ve seen the impact of book manifest in a number of interesting ways, one of which I was spoiled with last night at a Meetup for practitioners of the the book. Think Bible camp meets Business Models. Held at Toronto’s Center for Social Innovation (where else), a group of highly motivated business thinkers assembled to skype-meet the book’s co-author Alex Osterwalder (pictured to the left with event co-organizer Satish Kanwar from JetCooper), learn from some experts on how the Canvas could be used and most importantly, workshop in sub groups to create new and disruptive business models using the Canvas as our facilitator. I expect there will be a stream of dialog in the next few days (I’d say the Twitter stream was not as useful as normal because of the hands-on approach to the evening) but I wanted to touch on something that popped up when we were wrapping up at the end of the night.
A couple of groups joked that one of the challenges to the Canvas exercise was unifying all the intelligent minds in each group. As we get more educated and sophisticated in our thinking, a critical challenge for tomorrow’s companies will be how to ensure collaboration trumps competition. To be fair, I think competition can be healthy but when it comes to determining your company’s strategy and executing it, cohesion is essential. I’ve thought of this challenge often but more from a sports perspective – i.e. logically you want a team of superstars but if everyone is used to being ‘the man’, how do you keep everyone happy? Certainly, there are elements of culture and individual personality to consider here, but a large among of this cohesion will be formed when everyone feels like they’ve contributed to arriving at the decision. Again, this precisely is what makes the case for trying the collaborative Canvas approach even stronger.
What do you have to lose by not trying…well, other than your company of course.
4 Comments
1 Azra wrote:
I’m not sure if I understand fully what the Canvas is all about. Could anyone shed some more light on it?
[Reply]
adil Reply:
December 1st, 2009 at 7:25 pm
Ryan responded (#3) with a really good link that will give you a good idea of what the Canvas is.
[Reply]
2 Milan Davidovic wrote:
From the preview PDF, it looks like a nice book for anyone who doesn’t like too much text. And that’s not a dig, because from my tech writing work I know perfectly well that *sometimes* pictures get the job better than words, so a judicious mix of text and graphics is typically the key to success in disseminating information.
On the other hand, if you have a bias for text (as I do), it takes a bit of getting used to.
Although I don’t plan to have my own business, the ideas in this book might be useful for anyone in an organization looking to clarify what their role is and maybe do a little of that “intrapreneuring” stuff.
Thanks for sharing this with us.
[Reply]
adil Reply:
December 1st, 2009 at 7:28 pm
I agree Milan, I don’t think this is exclusively for people who are starting new businesses – I think this is just a good resource in general for anyone involved in an organization.
Thanks for the contribution and for pointing out the broken link.
[Reply]
3 @clickryan wrote:
Was at the #bmgenTO event last night (Nov 30,2009) in Toronto, Canada. The event was great and there were a bunch of game changers in the making. We had amazing facilitators and Satish @skanwar gets #Kudos for bringing it all together. Thanks JetCooper peepls
Here is the best way to get a snapshot / taste’test of what the Canvas is ….Business Model Generation – A handbook for Visionaries, Game Changers and Challengers News Remo Knops’ Personal Blog http://bit.ly/5bbLgZ
best of luck to all new budding gameChangers
@clickryan
[Reply]
adil Reply:
December 1st, 2009 at 7:24 pm
Thanks for the link Ryan, I’ll make sure to point Azra towards it.
Agreed on the great night and the big thanks to the organizers. Hoping there will be more.
Cheers
[Reply]
4 Malcolm Bastien wrote:
I agree with you. Maybe we were sort of competing for being “the person” who came up with the idea that made it on the canvas. Or maybe people’s understandings of each of the quadrants were mingled and different, not everyone had actually read the book by the time the event came around.
It seems appropriate that if there are more than 3 or 4 people then a facilitator or a leader would be needed to avoid chaos in a bm canvas session.
On the flip side, maybe as fairly beginners with the canvas it took longer because we had to come to a group agreement each time a new post-it went up on the canvas, say we were experts with the canvas and had just gone through the process a dozen times before, it’s possible a lot of the same notes would go up without any discussion and be almost like a reflex.
[Reply]
adil Reply:
December 2nd, 2009 at 10:12 am
Malcolm – hadn’t thought about your last point and I think its a valuable one as it kind of mirrors the whole innovative startup vs. monolithic big org situation. Not being exports allowed us to explore everything without blinders or pre-conceived notions which potentially lead to better thinking. Sure it made us shy at first, but the pressure to produce eventually broke that down and we made something out of it.
Thanks for the thoughts and I’m sorry we didn’t get a chance to meet there. Next time.
[Reply]